Should I worry about +ED for an Enigma?

First time Enigma creator here. I've heard superior items that have the +ed% pack a super cost to repair. I don't wanna break the bank but there's a lot of info out there like

- Defence on armor doesn't matter all that much

- put it in armor that you can get to str requirements without investing any or little str points I. Your attributes to put into vitality

-people pay an arm and a leg for the +ed%...so it's kind of conflicting on what I should do


Character details
Hammerdin
HoTO

Shako w/p

Topaz
Spirit w +45 fire +80 res for the rest

Magefist
2 30 mf nagelrings (though thinking of using a soj I found

String of Ears for the protection
War travs 50%mf


Was currently using skin of viper magi but with Enigma I'm going to drop under the 125% fcr so may need to work around there. Also I won't be max res anymore...hmmm

Merc

Tal Rasha with an

Um
Treatury
Giant

Eth

Thresher with Insight


Any advice on armor swaps or what base to put Enigma on would be greatly appreciated. I have 4 mules of socket armor so have a bit to choose from

If you were able to farm an Enigma, the extra gold cost to repair shouldn't really matter. If it really means that much to you, you could use an

Ort rune to repair it.

The "+str" argument depends entirely on the rest of your intended final gear.

If everything is relatively low in str req, you may as well get a low str req Enigma base to save yourself the trouble. Typically everything being low means you're not looking at higher def elites across the board and don't care much about def anyways so why would the Enigma be any different?

If however you aim to use things like

Steelrend or

Veil of Steel for example (even though you won't use those, what with being a hammerdin and all), Enigma only covers a fraction of their str req meaning you can go up to an

Archon Plate without wasting any extra strength points. In that case, the higher the armor, the more def (=benefit, even if low) you get, without any wasted stat points.

As for the repair cost argument, I never understood that. People make it sound as though it breaks every single game and as if gold were hard to get. Every time I hear that from someone, I honestly feel like I'm playing a different game than they are.

Personally, I always use an

Archon Plate as a base no matter what (nothing higher due to the run speed loss which does matter [to me] despite having

Teleport). Unless I prefer the looks of a

Wire Fleece or the like. That however just isn't the case for me in D2:R, despite having been true for half the chars in the original D2.

If you can find one and afford it, I'd say go for the ED as well unless you have some "out of Principle" reason not to. But repair cost as an argument? Ugh..

I was trying out different armors and the

Gothic Plate looks the most fashionable on a sorc IMO. Oh wells time to farm another Enigma for a

Gothic Plate one.

Had a

Dusk Shroud that was nice armor level close to max on the mules and went with it. Enigma defense is 1218 so I'm happy. Thanks for the Insight!!

Anonemous wrote: 2 years ago

If you were able to farm an Enigma, the extra gold cost to repair shouldn't really matter. If it really means that much to you, you could use an

Ort rune to repair it.

It's

Ral to repair armour.

AGKS wrote: 2 years ago

Anonemous wrote: 2 years ago

If you were able to farm an Enigma, the extra gold cost to repair shouldn't really matter. If it really means that much to you, you could use an

Ort rune to repair it.

It's

Ral to repair armour.

Thanks for correction. I've been just using gold.

Anonemous wrote: 2 years ago

AGKS wrote: 2 years ago

Anonemous wrote: 2 years ago

If you were able to farm an Enigma, the extra gold cost to repair shouldn't really matter. If it really means that much to you, you could use an

Ort rune to repair it.

It's

Ral to repair armour.

Thanks for correction. I've been just using gold.

I usually wait until the durability is like 5/20, then i will use a

Ral to repair it. But if i were to find a random

Ral and with space constraint, i will just repair it on the spot.

I'd rather use armor without +ED, and then most likely the armor type that I can use on multiple chars - if needed.
Unless you have too many

Jah &

Ber runes lying around .

But mostly I see if I can somehow get one with maximal roll defense.

Whether the armor is now 15% ed or not, no one can actually see anymore anyway ... unless you sell them .


My Hammerdin has about 10,818 defense with

Mage Plate and Shield Buff (target dummy 25% hitchance).
With + 15% ED a defense of 11,036 (also 25% hitchance).

With

Archon Plate it would be 12,251 Defense (23%),
with + 15% ed 12,682 Defense (22%).

Logically, I would say the slightly better armor in this class is not worth the hassle.

For this I save 48 strength - which can be used for more life, block or even upgrade other parts of armor (which can be more useful for armor),
can use the armor on other characters and I prefer to gamble with the repair costs.

Above all, if you still have a Chains of Honor, Fortitude, etc. with +ED, it can quickly turn into gold collecting.

Alsvartr wrote: 2 years ago

My Hammerdin has about 10,818 defense with

Mage Plate and Shield Buff (target dummy 25% hitchance).
With + 15% ED a defense of 11,036 (also 25% hitchance).

With

Archon Plate it would be 12,251 Defense (23%),
with + 15% ed 12,682 Defense (22%).

For this I save 48 strength - which can be used for anything

This is all there is to the

Archon Plate vs

Mage Plate. With

Mage Plate you can spend literally zero stat points in strength as you can get 20 str from Torch and 10 from Anni. And if you can afford Enigma, you can afford those two as well.

Of course for someone who can use the strength and is within melee range all the time, go with the bulkier, even medium, armor. Barbarian, Fury Druid,...

Queegon wrote: 2 years ago

With

Mage Plate you can spend literally zero stat points in strength as you can get 20 str from Torch and 10 from Anni.

Anni can have +20, so with Torch it's +40 free stats.