21
replies
21721 views
Description
Hi all,
I have a question about an Infinity base. I almost have all the runes I need for my first Infinity! As you can imagine, it's been a long time coming — but now I need to figure out the base.
I currently have an Eth 4 OS CV but I hear that most people like the Thresher. The problem is that 4OS Eth threshers are selling for like a Vex or something right now, and that's really discouraging because it feels like it will take me forever to get one. I'm not worried about the +str requirement on the CV since my merc is currently using one and I'm not really worried about resale value since I doubt I'll ever part with it.
So I need some advice. What are the real pros to a Thresher over a CV and should I try and hold out for one? Or just make it in my CV base?
Thoughts and advice are appreciated.
Description by BillyMaysed
I have a question about an Infinity base. I almost have all the runes I need for my first Infinity! As you can imagine, it's been a long time coming — but now I need to figure out the base.
I currently have an Eth 4 OS CV but I hear that most people like the Thresher. The problem is that 4OS Eth threshers are selling for like a Vex or something right now, and that's really discouraging because it feels like it will take me forever to get one. I'm not worried about the +str requirement on the CV since my merc is currently using one and I'm not really worried about resale value since I doubt I'll ever part with it.
So I need some advice. What are the real pros to a Thresher over a CV and should I try and hold out for one? Or just make it in my CV base?
Thoughts and advice are appreciated.
Can be used to make Runewords:
Hi all,
I have a question about an Infinity base. I almost have all the runes I need for my first Infinity! As you can imagine, it's been a long time coming — but now I need to figure out the base.
I currently have an Eth 4 OS CV but I hear that most people like the Thresher. The problem is that 4OS Eth threshers are selling for like a Vex or something right now, and that's really discouraging because it feels like it will take me forever to get one. I'm not worried about the +str requirement on the CV since my merc is currently using one and I'm not really worried about resale value since I doubt I'll ever part with it.
So I need some advice. What are the real pros to a Thresher over a CV and should I try and hold out for one? Or just make it in my CV base?
Thoughts and advice are appreciated.
I have a question about an Infinity base. I almost have all the runes I need for my first Infinity! As you can imagine, it's been a long time coming — but now I need to figure out the base.
I currently have an Eth 4 OS CV but I hear that most people like the Thresher. The problem is that 4OS Eth threshers are selling for like a Vex or something right now, and that's really discouraging because it feels like it will take me forever to get one. I'm not worried about the +str requirement on the CV since my merc is currently using one and I'm not really worried about resale value since I doubt I'll ever part with it.
So I need some advice. What are the real pros to a Thresher over a CV and should I try and hold out for one? Or just make it in my CV base?
Thoughts and advice are appreciated.
Answeredby Haippari • 3 years ago•Go to post
Thresher and Giant Thresher have the fastest speed and are considered the best type of polearm for infinity. But they can get pricy. Colossus Voulge is the easiest to get because it rolls with max 4 sockets. If you care about reaching ias breakpoints get either Thresher. Expensive runes are wasted on mediocre polearms..
You can check the stats (and the minor damage differences) from http://classic.battle.net/diablo2exp/it ... arms.shtml
Thresher (either one) with Andariel's Visage with 15% ias jewel (15%ias/30%fire resist is optimal) and Treachery armor will just reach 4.54 attacks per second, which is pretty sweet for a weapon with 40% crushing blow.
On a personal note, i'm finishing up on the runes needed for Infinity myself and will be using (or buying) a Thresher (not Giant) for finishing it.
EDIT: Your CV with same gear would reach 3.84 attacks per second.
You can check the stats (and the minor damage differences) from http://classic.battle.net/diablo2exp/it ... arms.shtml
Thresher (either one) with Andariel's Visage with 15% ias jewel (15%ias/30%fire resist is optimal) and Treachery armor will just reach 4.54 attacks per second, which is pretty sweet for a weapon with 40% crushing blow.
On a personal note, i'm finishing up on the runes needed for Infinity myself and will be using (or buying) a Thresher (not Giant) for finishing it.
EDIT: Your CV with same gear would reach 3.84 attacks per second.
I offer Uber Service, Rush Service and have many items for sale, Add me on battle.net | Hoost07#1211
The Thresher seems to have a faster attack speed + lower req. for the Merc. Can't see any other pro, it has less dmg tho.
Prices are negotiable
Please DO NOT add me, before I accepted a trade or without comment, thanks!
Offers via pm will be ignored.
Please DO NOT add me, before I accepted a trade or without comment, thanks!
Offers via pm will be ignored.
i believe the big thing is attack speed with Thresher v cv. i could be wrong, but i believe that is the major difference. also grats on getting close to your Infinity. I am also getting close and am pretty stoked.
However, when it comes to Infinity the big thing is that aura and the minus to resistance that makes is awesome, along with some of the other awesome bonuses that it provides. id say if you really dont wanna wait to acquire a Vex than go for it, it probably wont make that much of difference.
However, when it comes to Infinity the big thing is that aura and the minus to resistance that makes is awesome, along with some of the other awesome bonuses that it provides. id say if you really dont wanna wait to acquire a Vex than go for it, it probably wont make that much of difference.
Thresher and Giant Thresher have the fastest speed and are considered the best type of polearm for Infinity. But they can get pricy. Colossus Voulge is the easiest to get because it rolls with max 4 sockets. If you care about reaching ias breakpoints get either Thresher. Expensive runes are wasted on mediocre polearms..
You can check the stats (and the minor damage differences) from http://classic.battle.net/diablo2exp/it ... arms.shtml
Thresher (either one) with Andariel's Visage with 15% ias jewel (15%ias/30%fire resist is optimal) and Treachery armor will just reach 4.54 attacks per second, which is pretty sweet for a weapon with 40% crushing blow.
On a personal note, i'm finishing up on the runes needed for Infinity myself and will be using (or buying) a Thresher (not Giant) for finishing it.
EDIT: Your CV with same gear would reach 3.84 attacks per second.
This post was marked as the best answer.You can check the stats (and the minor damage differences) from http://classic.battle.net/diablo2exp/it ... arms.shtml
Thresher (either one) with Andariel's Visage with 15% ias jewel (15%ias/30%fire resist is optimal) and Treachery armor will just reach 4.54 attacks per second, which is pretty sweet for a weapon with 40% crushing blow.
On a personal note, i'm finishing up on the runes needed for Infinity myself and will be using (or buying) a Thresher (not Giant) for finishing it.
EDIT: Your CV with same gear would reach 3.84 attacks per second.
Under optimal conditions (Attack Speed etc.) a Great Poleaxe does the most damage.
Calculated with Weapon, Andariels and Treachery or Fortitude.
But, a Thresher always gets 4 sockets in the socket quest, so if you find an Ethereal with 0 Sockets, you have your base item for free. Edit: 5 Sockets, info was wrong
In my opinion, it's all just theory anyway, because Infinity can roll with bad ED (it was like that for me, for example),
but on the other hand, you wipe out everything with Infinity before the Hireling comes to the opponent (yes, there are a few exceptions ... ).
Calculated with Weapon, Andariels and Treachery or Fortitude.
But, a Thresher always gets 4 sockets in the socket quest, so if you find an Ethereal with 0 Sockets, you have your base item for free. Edit: 5 Sockets, info was wrong
In my opinion, it's all just theory anyway, because Infinity can roll with bad ED (it was like that for me, for example),
but on the other hand, you wipe out everything with Infinity before the Hireling comes to the opponent (yes, there are a few exceptions ... ).
I made mine in Thresher and it make sense, the faster the attack speed, the faster you life leech back hence better survivability for your merch
I personally prefer gpa - even if it's just a bit slower than Thresher. More consistent dmg makes up for speed - and it even looks more solid. Hell, it's even 63 lvl - exactly for Ber
Bought 4os Eth one for Vex a couple of days ago - and i don't regret it one bit.
Update: finally got this beauty
Bought 4os Eth one for Vex a couple of days ago - and i don't regret it one bit.
Update: finally got this beauty
OP
Update: I decided to buy an Eth Thresher and try the cube recipe for sockets since this was a cheaper option.
This is how that went. Pain.
This is how that went. Pain.
I offer Uber Service, Rush Service and have many items for sale, Add me on battle.net | Hoost07#1211
4 OS Eth CV is honestly fine. Most people will skip on it because of its high strength requirement and low resale value. You mentioned you have enough strength and don't care about resale value. It has about the same average damage output as a Thresher. ~90 damage per hit on Colossus Voulge, ~90.5 on Thresher (these may be non-ethereal numbers, I can't remember). The IAS is slower, true, but unless you are using it to specifically kill bosses that your character can't kill, it only means you lifesteal slower on your merc (40% CB doesn't matter most of the time because your character will demolish most bosses before your merc's hits do anything). Many seasoned D2 players have Eth CV Infinitys, they use them because any time they find better bases they trade those bases for more value. The only real reason to not use a 4OS Eth CV is if you really feel like you will regret putting your 2 Ber, Mal, and Ist runes in there. Most people feel this is a waste. But you don't have to.
It is mainly aura and crushing blow. -%resistance does not apply to player attacks.
I would recommend Thresher/ Giant Thresher base but in the end - if you are not strictly biased by resale value, any elitte ethereal Polearm will work and any base picking is mostly min-maxing. For ethereal Colossus Voulge, you'll need to use Andariel's Visage for its strength bonus (not bad thing) which should be then Ral'd (-30% fire resistance otherwise).
The sooner you'll have your Infinity, the sooner you will be able to benefit from it. Holding the runes does no good to you.
This is a very good point about time = money, although at the point you're making an Infinity, a Vex shouldn't feel like a big deal...Cryptography wrote: 3 years agoIt is mainly aura and crushing blow. -%resistance does not apply to player attacks.
I would recommend Thresher/ Giant Thresher base but in the end - if you are not strictly biased by resale value, any elitte ethereal Polearm will work and any base picking is mostly min-maxing. For ethereal Colossus Voulge, you'll need to use Andariel's Visage for its strength bonus (not bad thing) which should be then Ral'd (-30% fire resistance otherwise).
The sooner you'll have your Infinity, the sooner you will be able to benefit from it. Holding the runes does no good to you.
It depends. Some ten or more years ago, very little part of playerbase paid attention to Infinity base. CV was most popular choice due to ease of acquiring and it hardly made difference - people could still clear game in minutes time.Bounder wrote: 3 years agoThis is a very good point about time = money, although at the point you're making an Infinity, a Vex shouldn't feel like a big deal...Cryptography wrote: 3 years agoIt is mainly aura and crushing blow. -%resistance does not apply to player attacks.
I would recommend Thresher/ Giant Thresher base but in the end - if you are not strictly biased by resale value, any elitte ethereal Polearm will work and any base picking is mostly min-maxing. For ethereal Colossus Voulge, you'll need to use Andariel's Visage for its strength bonus (not bad thing) which should be then Ral'd (-30% fire resistance otherwise).
The sooner you'll have your Infinity, the sooner you will be able to benefit from it. Holding the runes does no good to you.
That small bonus in attack speed may or may not matter and it is often subjective. I would probably make it in Thresher, too, but only because I personally have issue with making that stuff into less than best possible bases. I'd probably chase 15/3 base as well though benefit from it is negligible.
Btw - made some calculations to compare dps for all 5 bases. Took 300% ed and 80% ias setup. Interesting results:
1) GPA leads - about 2155 average dps, 4,14aps
2) Cryptic Axe - 2104 and 3,84aps;
3) Giant Thresher - 2097 and 4,54;
4) Thresher - 2079 and 4,54;
5) CV - 1989. Definitely crappiest - dmg identical to GPA, but 3,84aps... meh.
As I suspected earlier - consistency in this case is slightly better than 0,5fpa. The rest is personal choice tho.
1) GPA leads - about 2155 average dps, 4,14aps
2) Cryptic Axe - 2104 and 3,84aps;
3) Giant Thresher - 2097 and 4,54;
4) Thresher - 2079 and 4,54;
5) CV - 1989. Definitely crappiest - dmg identical to GPA, but 3,84aps... meh.
As I suspected earlier - consistency in this case is slightly better than 0,5fpa. The rest is personal choice tho.
Just cubed a 5 soc EThresher
Damage calculations for both normal and Jab attacks according to maxroll.gg
Mercenary is wearing Ethereal Andariel's Visage socketed with 15% Increased Attack Speed Jewel and Treachery in Ethereal Archon Plate.
Note! Higher attacks per second not only increase raw damage from skill but also increase successful Crushing Blow procs and leech life.
Colossus Voulge
Cryptic Axe
Giant Thresher
Great Poleaxe
Thresher
Mercenary is wearing Ethereal Andariel's Visage socketed with 15% Increased Attack Speed Jewel and Treachery in Ethereal Archon Plate.
Note! Higher attacks per second not only increase raw damage from skill but also increase successful Crushing Blow procs and leech life.
I like Cryptic Axe due to its lower str requirements, allowing me to swap it around more easily. In the end you want it mostly for its Conviction aura.
I got the ethereal CB, but sometimes it hits too hard, which is a pain when you are farming Nillitak and your merc allows him to transform the surroundings into a mine field even if you got Nature's Peace.
Now between CB and Thresher, Thresher is a little better IMO
I got the ethereal CB, but sometimes it hits too hard, which is a pain when you are farming Nillitak and your merc allows him to transform the surroundings into a mine field even if you got Nature's Peace.
Now between CB and Thresher, Thresher is a little better IMO
here is another option
cheapest base there is.
and look at that sweet Cyclone Armor
then you can use an Insight/ Prayer merc to keep your engery shield and life up.
this runeword is too expensive for Kasim to hold imo and the -50 light res is in the right hands.
cheapest base there is.
and look at that sweet Cyclone Armor
then you can use an Insight/ Prayer merc to keep your engery shield and life up.
this runeword is too expensive for Kasim to hold imo and the -50 light res is in the right hands.
Similar pages
Advertisment
Hide adsGreetings stranger!
You don't appear to be logged in...
99
Who is online
Users browsing Forums: DasNarf, larso1224, lno, ShadowHeart, Sturmfalke and 128 guests.
No matches
Hoost07
153