Can a throw barbarian full replenish an ethereal throw weapon with 100% Critical + Pierce?

Hi

As Throw mastery replenishes quantity on a critical hit.

If a barbarian reaches 100% (or almost) critical hit and 100% (or almost)

Pierce (so can get more than 1 critical hit with one swing), can he guarantee replenish an ethereal throwing weapon to full?

Yes, that's exactly the mechanics you aim at triggering as throw barb.

Edit : as Atari pointed out, combined with the chance NOT to consume.

Throwing Mastery provides a chance to not consume quantity, critical strikes with throwing weapons now replenish quantity and a chance to

Pierce. That alone can already be enough to replenish an ethereal throwing weapon. If you add additional

Pierce and/or deadly strike to that you will always have a fully replenished throwing weapon.

Hold up, I thought Deadly Strike and

Critical Strike did not trigger the

Throwing Mastery replenish quantity effect. Do I have that wrong?

Critical Strike it's pretty sure it works, it is in the very description of the skill.

Deadly strike is supposedly the same effect, but I am not sure it works here or not.

Necrarch wrote: 2 weeks ago

Critical Strike it's pretty sure it works, it is in the very description of the skill.

Deadly strike is supposedly the same effect, but I am not sure it works here or not.

The Amazon Basin seems to think

Critical Strike and skills like

Throwing Mastery are checked separately under the hood, which would make me think

Throwing Mastery would either think (1) all three are treated as crits for replenishment purposes, or (2) only crits from

Throwing Mastery count.

Aelanwyr wrote: 2 weeks ago

Necrarch wrote: 2 weeks ago

Critical Strike it's pretty sure it works, it is in the very description of the skill.

Deadly strike is supposedly the same effect, but I am not sure it works here or not.

The Amazon Basin seems to think

Critical Strike and skills like

Throwing Mastery are checked separately under the hood, which would make me think

Throwing Mastery would either think (1) all three are treated as crits for replenishment purposes, or (2) only crits from

Throwing Mastery count.

If the answer is (2), it certainly seems like the game runs the check on the

Throwing Mastery crit even when Deadly Strike triggers. That is, Deadly Strike doesn't seem to make the chance to replenish worse.

From what I read, Deadly Strike,

Critical Strike and Masteries all test separately, but only one of those trigger on each hit (if one trigger the others are not tested)
So in practice works like if there is only on test (with the chances of different sources "grouped multiplicatively")

Take that case
https://maxroll.gg/d2/d2planner/i03950w9

Critical Chance (Deadly Strike): 52 (37+15) |

Highlord's Wrath +

Guillaume's Face
Critical Chance (

Critical Strike): 32 | Level 3 | Peace and +1 skills
Critical Chance (

Throwing Mastery): 29 | Level 21

Total Critical Chance: 77%
77% = (52 + 15.36 + 9.4656)
15.36 = (100 - 52) * 32%
9.4656= (100 - 52 - 15.36) * 29%

So I assume that the

Throwing Mastery effect happens when you get a Critical hit, considering the total chance and not just the

Throwing Mastery chance

As the three sources are grouped multiplicatively, it is actually impossible to get 100% Critical Chance by combining the 3 sources (but you can get really close )
The only way is to get 100% is to have 100% from a single source

fredkid wrote: 2 weeks ago

From what I read, Deadly Strike,

Critical Strike and Masteries all test separately, but only one of those trigger on each hit (if one trigger the others are not tested)
So in practice works like if there is only on test (with the chances of different sources "grouped multiplicatively")

So I assume that the

Throwing Mastery effect happens when you get a Critical hit, considering the total chance and not just the

Throwing Mastery chance

Correct,

Throwing Mastery

Critical Strike,

Critical Strike oskill (from Peace), and Deadly Strike all count as critical hits for the purpose of TM's replenish on crit. They are indeed all separate rolls and only one of them can succeed at once. Crits also count as non-consume, so any crit is guaranteed to replenish one quantity.

The chance to crit is rolled when the weapon is thrown, so piercing and critting multiple enemies doesn't replenish any more than throwing and critting at empty air.

So yeah for the OP, there's no way to 100% guarantee a crit but you can turn the odds very heavily in your favor by getting as high of a

Throwing Mastery level and stacking as much

Critical Strike and Deadly Strike as you can.

Highest you can get (with a skill shrine) is level 40

Throwing Mastery (33% crit strike, 62% non-consume), level 10

Critical Strike (56% crit strike), and 87% Deadly Strike. That gives you a 0.67 * 0.38 * 0.44 * 0.13 = 0.01456312 * 100 = 1.456312% chance of consuming quantity (all crit and non-consume rolls fail), 2.376088% chance of non-consume (all crit rolls fail but non-consume succeeds), and 96.1676% chance of replenishing (any crit roll succeeds). Hopefully I did the math correctly.
https://maxroll.gg/d2/d2planner/lq57o02o

DarkMaster wrote: 2 weeks ago

The chance to crit is rolled when the weapon is thrown, so piercing and critting multiple enemies doesn't replenish any more than throwing and critting at empty air.

Do you mean that:
if you don't roll critical on throw the main target and everybody the attack

Pierce through will take normal damage
and if you roll critical on throw the main target and everybody the attack

Pierce through will take "double damage"
?

fredkid wrote: 2 weeks ago

DarkMaster wrote: 2 weeks ago

The chance to crit is rolled when the weapon is thrown, so piercing and critting multiple enemies doesn't replenish any more than throwing and critting at empty air.

Do

Um mean that:
if you don't roll critical on throw the main target and everybody the attack

Pierce through will take normal damage
and if you roll critical on throw the main target and everybody the attack

Pierce through will take "double damage"
?

Nope, the crit chance is still rolled with every individual collision. You can not crit on the initial throw, then have it

Pierce the first monster then have it crit on the second or third monster. It won't replenish any quantity though because it's still only rolled on the initial throw.

So
critical is tested on each hit (my initial thought)
But the replenish trigger may happen only on the first hit of the attack (not what I though initially)

OK