If you could up uniques to compete with runewords, what would they be ?

For those still wondering: "On strike" and "On kill" effects only work with weapon strikes and weapon kills.

Angel_Witch wrote: 1 year ago

Thanks for the feedback, but I am pretty sure that this effect would only trigger on physical attacks that kill the target and not spells - Breath of the Dying has this effect wtih

Poison Nova already and it doesn't work on any Spell and on some special cases also not on attacks (for example:

Whirlwind). So wouldn't work with

Hurricane at all and for

Lightning Fury it probably would only work on the targets that do die from the main projectile.

ahhh, you're right. oh well, it would still be a cool option to get some AOE damage on melee characters.

I think the best way to make Unique good again is to create some much better jewels. Like FCR or +skill jewel

DerTwo wrote: 1 year ago

I think the best way to make Unique good again is to create some much better jewels. Like FCR or +skill jewel

That's indeed a way, as it would increase the value of sockets. But would be a breakchanger for the rest, but definitely an interesting idea. A 5% FCR could definitely be a cool affix for a jewel, so would be a 5% frw, 3% life steal or 3% mana steal.

Any other suggestions, if possible linked to specific builds that would build competitors to Hoto / Spirit ? Perhaps some Sin

Claws ?

> While I am at assassins add a -15% requirements to Nat armor and Nat

Claws would be a good start + a level required of 60 for the highest pieces, to use the full Nat set. Perhaps to ALL elite sets actually, align to level 60 max

Let's think of others :
- Sorc : Weapons for sorc are already BiS (Eschuta / Death Fathom) and actually new Obessions fills in the gap. Uniques are missing here;,

Lidless Wall is by no means an endgame item so not much to say. Armor,

Ormus is already rather good but may need at little up to compare to Enigma or CoH ? I am not playing Sorc, would

Ormus Robes need something ? Perhaps 2 sockets by default ?

Tal set is already the best set in the game so not sure if needs something, even if replacing life leech / mana leech by life after kill / mana after kill would make more sense for

Tal

Mask - but would not work any more for mercs. Your thoughts ?

--> Missed that Asha suggested to add something to Eschuta. Perhaps 1-2 os to allow facets ?

- Pala ; Well, as long as Grief is not nerfed there is little to do for weapon. HoZ is already excellent, and so is Exile that I can't consider a "too used" runeword. More worried about the armor slot. Upping

Tyrael's Might to add +1 to

Teleport would be really nice as stated above !

- Druid : I don't know that class at all, would need some advice...

- Barb : Not sure to know what to do here neither... improving Immortal King's armor, would that work ? +

Corpsemourn as suggested above seems... real fun (even if removing a horking chance - not only for Barb obviously).

- Zon : Mavina's Caster is an obvious choice. Would 2 or 3 sockets to it make it a viable weapon ? + the same for M'avina's armor ? Can good old

Windforce or

Lycander's Aim come with 2 sockets each (and Witchwild 3 to make it up for it) ?

Titan's Revenge is already great, not much to say.

I know well necros, not too badly Sins, but less the others so please provide ideas

I don´t think upping uniques is the right move. Better nerf the runewords, that are way too strong.

shrodo wrote: 1 year ago

I don´t think upping uniques is the right move. Better nerf the runewords, that are way too strong.

That's an idea, why not starting a new thread for this ?

shrodo wrote: 1 year ago

I don´t think upping uniques is the right move. Better nerf the runewords, that are way too strong.

I have thought about this too and while I generally like this idea, if the past is any indication, Blizzard would leave the ones already made as-is and let the nerf only affect newly created rune words, which would mean the old (pre-nerf) ones would become astronomically expensive post-nerf. Also, if they were to actually do this, wouldn't people just rush to create as many of the pre-nerf versions as possible ASAP to sell for big $$ post-nerf? I don't know how they could go about this is in a good way.

But yeah, create a new topic to discuss that, I think

ShadowHeart wrote: 1 year ago

shrodo wrote: 1 year ago

I don´t think upping uniques is the right move. Better nerf the runewords, that are way too strong.

I have thought about this too and while I generally like this idea, if the past is any indication, Blizzard would leave the ones already made as-is and let the nerf only affect newly created rune words, which would mean the old (pre-nerf) ones would become astronomically expensive post-nerf. Also, if they were to actually do this, wouldn't people just rush to create as many of the pre-nerf versions as possible ASAP to sell for big $$ post-nerf? I don't know how they could go about this is in a good way.

But yeah, create a new topic to discuss that, I think

Blizz has already said they don't want to nerf anything. Introduce new stuff every so often, perhaps buff some existing stuff but not nerf anything. Which makes sense because yes, some folks (myself included) would immediately go and make 20 more Enigmas to sell post-nerf for infinite Jahs each.

Then again, not like Blizz reliably does what they said they would.

Schnorki wrote: 1 year ago

Blizz has already said they don't want to nerf anything. Introduce new stuff every so often, perhaps buff some existing stuff but not nerf anything. Which makes sense because yes, some folks (myself included) would immediately go and make 20 more Enigmas to sell post-nerf for infinite Jahs each.

Then again, not like Blizz reliably does what they said they would.

Personally think this is a ridiculously silly statement from Blizzard to not considering nerfs at. It's like having an equation with two variables and you only look at one of them. As far as I am concerend, nerfs are even more important than buffs because buffs only get into the head of the people when they see that their previous way of doing things isn't as effective anymore.

In this case I'd actually for once like when Blizzard does something else from what they were saying.

Schnorki wrote: 1 year ago

Blizz has already said they don't want to nerf anything. Introduce new stuff every so often, perhaps buff some existing stuff but not nerf anything. Which makes sense because yes, some folks (myself included) would immediately go and make 20 more Enigmas to sell post-nerf for infinite Jahs each.
Then again, not like Blizz reliably does what they said they would.

For arguments sake lets assume the nerf would be that Enigma doesnt grant +1

Teleport anymore. That would be true for alle enigmas, new one and already existing ones. So it wouldn´t impact the pricing in the way you are proposing.

Hmm, it would be a bit of a controversial move to nerf items that people already have in their possession, as it could potentially ruin builds (depending on what the nerf actually is, like anything that lets you reach a breakpoint for IAS, FCR or FHR). In the past when Blizz has re-worked items (uniques), they let the old ones be, didn't they? Also, lets say Enigma lost

Teleport, wouldn't everyone be going back to only/mostly farm with Sorcs like in the really old days? It would just reduce diversity in builds used for farming, wouldn't it? In that particular case, I think I'd prefer if they added the

Teleport oskill to one or two more items, like the suggestion here for

Tyrael's Might. Maybe. I don't know lol.

I would remove the

Teleport proc on

The Oculus. That's all it needs to suddenly be a viable weapon that competes with HOTO and

Eschuta's Temper. It's in a really great place with all its other stats to be a viable choice, but the suicide proc is just... awful.

Ideally any sort of Major Balance Patch would drop along with a new Ladder-Season and then perhaps just adjust things that are bugged or broken along the way.

Necrarch wrote: 1 year ago

- Zon : Mavina's Caster is an obvious choice. Would 2 or 3 sockets to it make it a viable weapon ? + the same for M'avina's armor ? Can good old

Windforce or

Lycander's Aim come with 2 sockets each (and Witchwild 3 to make it up for it) ?

Back in LoD, I had

M'avina's Caster with a 40/15 max jewel. It still wasn't good enough because that only brought it up to 228% ED and 45-251 weapon damage. The bow simply isn't competitive from a physical damage standpoint. Now if you want to gear it towards frostmaidens which is really the only subclass that even has a use for the set, then the cold damage bonuses are currently nonexistent. Maybe you could argue 2-3 +5/-5 cold facets socketed in it might make it better. I say it probably won't make much of a difference.

The real forgotten unique is

Eaglehorn. It simply sucks right now. I found one running WSK yesterday and I'm not even sure why I picked it up other than to have a look at it. It's not a remotely competitive option right now. As a 1.08 unique, it was designed to slot below

Windforce back in a time when uniques had very few interesting gameplay features. At least

Windforce has managed to stay relevant after 20+ years.

Eaglehorn is quintessential

Charsi food.

Interesting. What about adding to

M'avina's Caster some cold piercing like

Wizendraw then + a socket ?

As for

Eaglehorn, you cannot save all uniques ^^

I think that would be good.

Wizendraw could be a blueprint for

M'avina's Caster. Bring over its enemy cold resist reduction and add a couple of sockets to it, and M'avina's would at least stand out a little more to frostmaidens. Those two bows are already kind of similar otherwise with the attack rating and

Magic Arrow bonuses.

I'd also give it at least 33%

Pierce to make up for how using the full set would rule out

Razortail. I'd also consider adding

Freezing Arrow skill points to it.

As a set item and not a unique, perhaps it's not supposed to be as strong of a standalone piece as other unique weapons, but the other parts of M'avina's set are so underwhelming that the bow also needs to better bridge the gap between its current state and an actually desirable

Grand Matron Bow.

It still won't touch Faith in popularity, but it could at least be a viable alternative to Ice, which is already underwhelming in its own right for a

Jah and

Lo because the Amazon cold tree branch can't compete with the Sorceress's entire cold tree tab.

Hi all,

Thanks for your participation to this topic. Let's summarize the suggestions:

- Sets in general: make all set items that require a level more than 60 to be at 60. Rationale: make them useful before being overcomed by uniques and runewords.

- Necro:
>

Boneshade: +10% fcr from 25 to 35. Rationale: make it a competitor to HotO (more offense) and White (more fcr).

>

Marrowwalk: +10% frw or fhr, -15% requirements. Rationale : make them the standard for summoners, without needing so much strength.

>

Trang-Oul's Wing: add 2 open sockets. Rationale : allow more flexibility, especially Poison facets for Poisonmancers.

- Amazon:
>

M'avina's Caster : add some cold resistance piercing like on

Wizendraw +2 os +

Pierce % (20? 33?). Rationale : super weak now, will be way better for Frost Maidens.

>

Lycander's Aim : now comes with 1-2 os. Rationale : make it more competitive.

>

Windforce : now comes with 1-2 os. Same rationale.

>

Witchwild String: now comes with 2-3 os. Rationale : matching previous ones.

>

Eaglehorn : Do something BIG for that one, it needs it ! No idea on what though. ... perhaps 5 os! Or something thematic like

Tornado /

Cyclone Armor 0skills ?

- Sorceress:
>

Eschuta's Temper: Adding some elemental piercing. To be carefully measured to make it slightly better, not OP. Why not 10% all 3 (f/c/l)?

>

The Oculus: change

Teleport direction from "semi random" to "opposite of the damage source". Rationale : can still make surprises but less seemingly random ones.

- Assassin:
>

Natalya's Shadow: now comes with 2-3 os, never 1, and -15% requirements. Rationale : avoid the ridiculous 1 os roll + make it less strength demanding to wear.

>

Natalya's Mark: add -10% requirements. Rationale : require less str/dex to wear.

- Druid:

>

Plague Bearer: add Poison damage lower resistance effect (perhaps -15%?). Rationale : help

Rabies druids.

Barbarian:

>

Immortal King's Soul Cage: now comes with 2 os. Rationale : add flexibility.

>

Immortal King's Stone Crusher : change IAS from 40 to 60. Rationale: every user already adds a

Shael it seems, or even 2.

- Others:
>

Corpsemourn: replace

Corpse Explosion charges by 33% chance to cash when killkng enemy. Rationale : fun to add ability for melee to explorer bodies.

>

Tyrael's Might: add +1 to

Teleport Oskill. Rationale: make a competitor for Enigma for the rarest item of the game.

>

Black Hades:
Add +1 to all skills. Rationale : make it useful.

>

Head Hunter's Glory:
Make sockets 2-3 instead of 1-3 to avoid the 1 fail. Add some lower resists effect. Rationale : give it extra efficiency.

- Jewels:

Add the following suffixes: 5% fcr, 3% frw, 3% life steal, 3% mana steal, for magic only. Would make them - and the corresponding sockets so uniques- more valuable.

Have I forgotten something guys ?
Thanks !