there's no reason to be upset about people picking up THEIR quest kill drops.
Uh... if they can't kill how is it theirs?
I don't believe that the premise here is that they paid for a service. I think the premise is that help was offered where they couldn't do it on their own. It is possible to steal someone else's drop. It goes like this... someone kills something... you sneak in and take the drop. Simple as that. They created the drop, you got it instead.
Drops belong to whomever picks them up first IMO. They don't "belong" to anyone. They used to belong to the monster, then they belong to the Ground before someone grabs them. Game is too fun to get upset about missed drop pickups. You can always find that stuff in solo play.
All trades are negotiable within reason Check out my "Free Stuff" tab for...FREE STUFF! I can help with DClone/Ubers/Ancients/Socket Rushes, just ask! Please only add me on bnet if you contact me here first.
Drops belong to whomever picks them up first IMO. They don't "belong" to anyone. They used to belong to the monster, then they belong to the Ground before someone grabs them. Game is too fun to get upset about missed drop pickups. You can always find that stuff in solo play.
Obviously the drop is generated by the person who killed the monster. It's their MF, and their damage, and their click that ultimately generate the drop. If someone can swipe it, that's the game. But that person should probably not decide to be a jerk about it.
What's hard about this? Why are people trying so hard to over think this stuff?
I mean anyone can do what they please in a multiplayer lobby, obviously, but lets be honest and truthful with what we're talking about lol. Obviously something you dropped from a monster you killed would be assumed to be yours. This is pretty basic etiquette that applies across most things in life. You can ofc personally think it's okay / not a big deal / whatever rationale but why pretend this discussion is about anything else lol
Obviously the drop is generated by the person who killed the monster. It's their MF, and their damage, and their click that ultimately generate the drop. If someone can swipe it, that's the game. But that person should probably not decide to be a jerk about it.
What's hard about this? Why are people trying so hard to over think this stuff?
Exactly this
♥♥♥ SC ladder & non-ladder ♥♥♥
Feel free to message me on discord @kerph for a quick reply
And the "drops are a free for all" sentiment is in no way a rule, at best it's descriptive of what tends to occur in public games but it's not at all like a special inexorable part of diablo 2. People can wish and assert that it is an unwritten rule to justify their unsavoury behaviour but it doesn't make it true. Lol
♥♥♥ SC ladder & non-ladder ♥♥♥
Feel free to message me on discord @kerph for a quick reply
In a regular game, in practice, drops are a free for all. I don't think I've ever seen someone NOT try to grab a good item.
I do find the trailer comes and grabs your item annoying, and I do think proper etiquette should be that if you clearly were not involved with the kill, you shouldn't grab the item if it is a clear high desirability item (high/mid rune, good unique).
More commonly, it's Chaos and it's hard to say who killed what.
For this specific case however, the "help me kill this boss", I would say:
1) This already happens with people requesting help on this site with ubers and uber ancients. And NO ONE thinks the helper should take the prize (jewel). They are there to to "help", they are not there for hire.
Of course in this case the work split is a bit different, it is much more time investment to find the keys/statues than to do the actual uber fight.
To me the quest drop is kind of in between. It's hard for me to see either side having an iron clad expectation of what is fair.
And also - if they aren't helping to kill the boss, how are they sniping the loot? Unless it is a sorc with TK, you would be able to beat them to it.
And the "drops are a free for all" sentiment is in no way a rule, at best it's descriptive of what tends to occur in public games but it's not at all like a special inexorable part of diablo 2. People can wish and assert that it is an unwritten rule to justify their unsavoury behaviour but it doesn't make it true. Lol
I would love to see you try and play detective after an 8-player Baal kill to find out who really dealt the killing blow lmao
The drops are a free-for-all. That's just how the game was designed. Hate the game, not the player.
And using the same logic, one can also say:
And the "drops belong to who dealt the killing blow" sentiment is in no way a rule, at best it's descriptive of what tends to not occur in public games but it's not at all like a special inexorable part of diablo 2. People can wish and assert that it is an unwritten rule to justify their selfish behaviour but it doesn't make it true. Lol
Help is typically a selfless act. If your help is conditional, you should communicate that to the other party and come to an agreement.
If you offer what I ask for, you can add me on bnet for faster trade.
would love to see you try and play detective after an 8-player Baal kill to find out who really dealt the killing blow lmao
Obviously that's different why are we playing gotcha-games? The topic of the op was not an 8-player Baal run where it's impossible to determine who dropped what, i'm not (and i don't think op or anyone else is) referring to that lol
♥♥♥ SC ladder & non-ladder ♥♥♥
Feel free to message me on discord @kerph for a quick reply
List trades and earn trust
Level up as you post
Give and Receive Likes
Discreet Notifications
Avatar & Profile customisation
Private Messaging
Bookmark Pages & Posts
Use Drafts & Revisions
Attach Images
Squelches this trader, making their offers on your trades invisible to anyone except themselves. Their trade listings will also be hidden from your marketplace.
Your squelch list can be managed and edited from Top right dropdown > Account Prefs > Squelches.
why are we playing gotcha-games? The topic of the op was not an 8-player 
Curumo69
Google Adsense [Bot]
krathkor
Rhaegar86
departure
318