Hiding magic items but show charms on loot filter

Show should override though the order matters I believe (though I haven't actively re-confirmed that tbh).

However, if you're looking at "magic vs. magic", you don't need 2 rules.

Just make 1 rule:
- Hide
- Magic
- Under equipment, select everything (category checks) and then de-select the few things you do still want to see, such as charms under accessories

That way, you're hiding all magic drops except for the ones you've de-selected again to account for charms, jmods and so on.

TeleTabitha wrote: 1 hour ago

Wouldn't it be more sensible to select all the Items to show, instead of deselecting all the items you don't want to show late game?

The game starts off showing everything.
So you need a "hide" rule no matter what.
De-selecting them in that hide rule means you only need to deal with 1 rule.
Hiding everything in one rule and then showing them 1 by 1 in a different rule just introduces room for mistakes and instability (as is the case for the OP here).

And since you can select the entire category at once in the hide rule, it only takes 3 clicks to set the starting point (1 each for armor, weapons and accessories).
That's less extra clicks/effort than creating a 2nd rule to show.

So you're "doing less", end up with half the rules to manage, less room for error and get the same end result.
De-selecting the things you want to show within the hide rule is definitely the way to go.


Disclaimer:
That does not apply for ethereal/socketed as that category overlaps with normal/superior/... so these should actually get their own specific show rule.

If you start out with just one single universal hide then yes, it should end up showing your show rules "no matter what". Unless the interaction with the hide rule fails as seems to be the case for the OP.

Personally, I prefer my rules cleaner and specific. I don't want one universal "everything" rule.

So there's a hide normal, a hide inferior, a hide superior, ... basically, a hide for each distinct category of base item. And those simply have those items de-selected that I don't want hidden, effectively making them "hide all X except for Y".

Plus some have additional show rules. Ethereal/socketed is one as that overlaps with other base categories and hence can't be handled cleanly as part of the hide rules and requires a distinct show rule following up on them. And the others are "purpose specific". E.g. for sets and uniques I have a general hide rule that hides all of them except for the ones I would pick up for myself. Both then also have 2 distinct show rules each. One to show those pieces I still need for the chronicle so that is handled independent of other purposes. And one for those I'd only pick up to trade as I don't want them for myself but they do have enough trade value.

If you start out with a universal hide, you then simply need a show for every single category which basically nets you the same amount of rules in total plus the universal hide on top, always giving you at least one more.

Either approach works though so I guess in the end, it is simply a matter of preference. I just don't want 2 rules having to interact to create the same outcome I could do in one unless there's a logical/organizational reason for it (such as tracking missing chronicle drops separately).