Need some help with Paladin shields.

Hi to all the Pala nerds!

I haven't played Palas a lot. So it is really hard for me to determine if a shield is worth keeping/trading. The possible combinations of lvlreq - statsreq - 3/4os - ar/dmg automod - (non)etheral - block - defense are just too many...

Some basics are easy. Everything with good block, 40+ar und 4os has always good value. And for 3os the etheral elite shields with high ar are very sought after. But I'd like to understand it a bit more. For example how much block are players willing to

Sacrifice for a good dmg/def/ar value? Where are dmg automods prefered over ar automods? Questions over questions...

If you don't mind, I'd love to get some evaluation on the usefullness of the following Pala shields. It would be awesome to get some arguments why or why not a shild is (not) valuable. And maybe we can have some discussion on shields of compareable value; like in what kind of situation would one or the other be better, playstyle preferences and things like that.

Already a big "thank you" to everyone willing to help to bring some clarification in this blur of Pala shield properties!

ar shields:

Spoiler

dmg shields:

Spoiler

Yes, anything with +45 resistances is valuable. The only question is how much, and for how long will you sell it—a week, a month, a year?

Secondly, when composing runewords, some stats are always randomized—this has a much greater impact on effectiveness than the base stats of shield.

IMHO, it makes sense to think about this if you have a level 99 paladin and a ton of runes like

Ber.

And then, you can always create a mule character and drop these shields there.

rixsen wrote: 2 hours ago

Hi to all the Pala nerds!

I haven't played Palas a lot. So it is really hard for me to determine if a shield is worth keeping/trading. The possible combinations of lvlreq - statsreq - 3/4os - ar/dmg automod - (non)etheral - block - defense are just too many...

Some basics are easy. Everything with good block, 40+ar und 4os has always good value. And for 3os the etheral elite shields with high ar are very sought after. But I'd like to understand it a bit more. For example how much block are players willing to

Sacrifice for a good dmg/def/ar value? Where are dmg automods prefered over ar automods? Questions over questions...

If you don't mind, I'd love to get some evaluation on the usefullness of the following Pala shields. It would be awesome to get some arguments why or why not a shild is (not) valuable. And maybe we can have some discussion on shields of compareable value; like in what kind of situation would one or the other be better, playstyle preferences and things like that.

Already a big "thank you" to everyone willing to help to bring some clarification in this blur of Pala shield properties!

ar shields:

Spoiler

PalaShieldsar.gif

dmg shields:

Spoiler

PalaShieldsdmg.gif

That 4os Vortex Shieldis a keeper for sure. Perfect roll (+45) has definite value.

Going beyond that, if you already are able to hit the 75% max block chance through other gear (

Guardian Angel, etc) or dexterity points (for example, if you already need to invest 136 dex to use a

Phase Blade which brings you to 75%) then the

Vortex Shield becomes best choice IMO.

Personally if it were me I'd use it even if I had to

Sacrifice a little bit to only hit 66-67 block or so, just because I myself like high def and the perfect roll is very enticing.

Only thing better IMO would be an upped and

Um'd HoZ, especially if youre playing FoH where +skills have a huge effect on your damage output.