Pala: PC +40/45 charm VS 3/20/20

I wonder if anyone ever made a calculation whether it's more benefical to have either of these charms; meaning full inventory with 3/20/20 or the corresponding amount of PC charm and 3/20/20 to fill the remaining empty slots. The build is either zealot, smiter, or charger (or hybrid as i do now with new implemented keyboard mapping)
I'd be grateful for any information in that regards. But maybe its obvious, than apologies for this noob question

forgot, grand max dmg / Ar / +life charm should be considered as well, since they can go higher with maxdmg

3/20/20 is far superior when considering non hammer pally.

kevdrogo wrote: 4 years ago

3/20/20 is far superior when considering non hammer pally.

I am usually not that nerdy, but I made an example myself (hopefully i didn't make any major mistakes)

Just considering the aspect of pure dmg output here is a small hypothetical calculation (provided you play pure zealot):

Base Dmg = 50 - 100

Dmg bonus due to Sacrifice and Zeal at skill level 19 = 318%
Dmg bonus due to Sacrifice and Zeal at skill level 20 (using PC charm) = 336%

Dmg at skill lvl 19 = 159 - 318
Dmg at skill lvl 20 = 168 - 336

3 x 3/20/20 charms replace 1 PC charm, so +9 max dmg instead of +18%dmg increase

Dmg at skill lvl 19 with 3x 3/20/20 charm = 159 - 346

Average dmg Pc charm vs 3xmax dmg charm:

With PC charm: (168 + 336)/2 = 252
With 3x 3/20/20: (159 + 346)/2 = 252,5

Delta dmg Pc vs +3max dmg charm = 0,5

Maybe this is oversimplified or even wrong but at the moment I don't really see the big advantage of those small charms, provided your are merely interested in dmg output of course.
Please let me know your thoughts.